Looking at your example
it looks like you need your results in column H?
and the goals to sum is in column D?
try this copied down
=IF(AND('game data'!E1='Player games '!A$1,'game data'!D1>=1),SUMIF('game data'!E1:E$2,'Player games '!A$1,'game data'!D1:D$2),"")
formula
for row 2 and copy down, are the results above correct?
=IF(AND('game data'!E2='Player games '!A$1,'game data'!D2>=1),SUMIF('game data'!E$2:E2,'Player games '!A$1,'game data'!D$2:D2),"")
because i put the sheet names in everywhere, you can use the formula in any sheet
Dave