I am finding some of your replies very confusing. I can't tell if you are saying things worked or didn't work.
=INDEX(Sheet1!$A:$A,COLUMNS($A1:A1))
So, if you question was answered to your satisfaction, what was the purpose of your last post?
Matters of a separate thread should be kept to that thread. You can "bump" that thread (by replying to it yourself) if it has not been resolved or gotten any recent responses.