Hi, I want to return all the different values in column e associated with all of the matching values in column b with a comma in between the values. I want this formula in column f. For example, cell b2=hammer, b3=hammer, b4= hammer and cell e2=a, e3=b and e=c. If I entered the formula in f2, I want it to return "a,b,c" without the quotes. F3 and f4 would be blank because I just want them combined into one cell. If that's not possible to have the blanks, I could remove duplicates from column b. Thank you