Losing my mind over this. Is my assignment incorrect or do I just not know what I'm doing? (regarding utility invoices & calendarizing data)

helnuma2k

New Member
Joined
Feb 14, 2023
Messages
10
Office Version
  1. 365
Platform
  1. Windows
I need to calculate the total # of calls, texts, & emails facilitated on a company's network each month from Jan 16 - Jan 17.

The issue: the data set given to me only contains Summary invoices, which show total volumes grouped by the type of usage over each individual invoice term. Since invoices cross multiple months, I need to calendarize them to appropriately split up the usage across each month.

I'm given 2 worksheets.

The 1st worksheet contains all 90 invoices (24 Call, 36 Text, 30 Email), the Total Usage (based on Usage Type) for that invoice, and the invoice's period start and end date. Here's a preview.

The 2nd worksheet gives the 3 Usage Curves (Calls, Texts, Emails) by average hourly usage by Usage Type from 1/1/16 to 1/31/17. So there are 24 rows for 1/1/16, 24 for 1/2/16, and so on until 1/31/17 to represent each hour of each day in each month. Here's a preview.

Using the 3 hourly usage curves, I need to calculate with formulas the total # of calls, texts, & emails in each month. I think I understand the concept behind calendarization, but I get confused by the last line of the exercise which says:
Manual sample calculations have been provided for Invoices 2 and 3 to show the solutions we're looking for
It's these 2 calculations that completely throw me off, because either there's a mistake in the data for those sample calculations, or I'm completely confused as to how to calendarize the data for those 2 Invoices.

Looking at Invoice 2 in the first worksheet, 959.36 of the total usage of 2519 was attributed to Jan 16 and the remaining 1559.64 was attributed to Feb 16.

To get to 959.36 for Jan, they used this formula:

Excel Formula:
=SUM(Part1_Usage_Curves!$E$461:$E$748)/SUM(Part1_Usage_Curves!$E$461:$E$1228)*$D6

which is basically:
[Sum of text usage from 1/20 to 1/31] / [Sum of text usage from 1/20 to 2/20] * [Total Usage on Invoice 2]

To get to 1559.64 for Feb, they used this formula:

Excel Formula:
=SUM(Part1_Usage_Curves!E749:E1228)/SUM(Part1_Usage_Curves!$E$461:$E$1228)*$D6

which is basically:
[Sum of text usage from 2/1 to 2/20] / [Sum of text usage from 1/20 to 2/20] * [Total Usage on Invoice 2]

None of their formulas make sense to me because Invoice 2 starts on 1/5 and ends on 2/5. So why would the calculation for the Jan month take the sum of usage from just 1/20 to 1/31, when the bill started much earlier?

Likewise, why is the calculation for the Feb month using dates from 2/1 to 2/20 when the invoice's end date is 2/5?

As you can tell, I'm a beginner at Excel and have trouble grasping what I need to do to make it easier to calculate these values. A big part of me thinks the way they did it for those 2 months is clearly wrong and that I should just restart the calendarization another way. But I have no idea, that's why I'm here for guidance.

Can anyone provide basic guidance as to either 1) how the sample calculations were calculated and whether the dates used are correct or 2) if the sample calculations are incorrect, then how do I approach the problem at all?

Basically, any sort of help would be much appreciated, I have a long night ahead of me haha. If it helps, here are the worksheets & edited prompt.
 
I'm sorry. , You're formulas in the first worksheet use data from a different section of what you posted. Can you post the relevant cells?
I'm sorry.

And, they are not the rules.. but more courtesy and highly encouraged. Many people can't install add ins on their computers, etc.
Let me retry this.

Worksheet 1 lists all the invoices, the usage type, and the total use through the invoice's stard & end date.

CES Excel Exercise.xlsx
ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRS
1Morgan Mobile
2
3Month Ending
4Invoice_#Usage_TypeTotal_UsagePeriod_StartPeriod_EndJan-16Feb-16Mar-16Apr-16May-16Jun-16Jul-16Aug-16Sep-16Oct-16Nov-16Dec-16Jan-17
5Invoice_1Calls34,5531/3/161/30/16
6Invoice_2Texts2,5191/5/162/5/16959.361,559.640.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.00
7Invoice_3Emails52,7401/9/162/9/1624,359.9428,380.060.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.000.00
8Invoice_4Texts40,0721/15/162/20/16
9Invoice_5Texts41,3811/18/162/21/16
10Invoice_6Emails3,4171/21/162/24/16
11Invoice_7Texts3,4601/24/162/23/16
12Invoice_8Calls43,5061/26/162/29/16
13Invoice_9Emails39,1191/31/163/5/16
14Invoice_10Texts55,6582/2/163/2/16
15Invoice_11Calls2,7372/7/163/11/16
16Invoice_12Emails42,3762/13/163/14/16
17Invoice_13Texts3,1382/17/163/17/16
18Invoice_14Calls1,5582/23/163/29/16
19Invoice_15Texts51,1492/27/164/2/16
20Invoice_16Emails2,1933/3/164/5/16
21Invoice_17Emails3,1283/8/164/9/16
22Invoice_18Texts1,4253/11/164/10/16
23Invoice_19Emails29,0223/16/164/14/16
24Invoice_20Calls39,6163/19/164/21/16
25Invoice_21Calls5,8523/23/164/21/16
26Invoice_22Emails9,6153/28/164/29/16
27Invoice_23Calls40,1593/31/165/2/16
28Invoice_24Texts6,4574/3/165/6/16
29Invoice_25Calls10,2234/8/165/11/16
30Invoice_26Texts9,4934/10/165/16/16
31Invoice_27Emails3,9664/15/165/20/16
32Invoice_28Texts41,2254/17/165/23/16
33Invoice_29Texts40,6524/22/165/25/16
34Invoice_30Emails29,1744/28/165/30/16
35Invoice_31Texts49,0835/4/166/7/16
36Invoice_32Calls13,7605/10/166/14/16
37Invoice_33Emails22,4615/14/166/17/16
38Invoice_34Texts15,9415/16/166/18/16
39Invoice_35Calls25,1605/19/166/17/16
40Invoice_36Emails15,5425/24/166/29/16
41Invoice_37Calls12,4135/30/166/29/16
42Invoice_38Texts13,7096/5/167/9/16
43Invoice_39Emails10,8906/10/167/14/16
44Invoice_40Texts17,9466/12/167/17/16
45Invoice_41Texts44,0566/14/167/20/16
46Invoice_42Emails28,0896/17/167/19/16
47Invoice_43Texts42,2436/23/167/26/16
48Invoice_44Calls23,5736/26/167/31/16
49Invoice_45Emails15,0317/2/168/4/16
50Invoice_46Texts9,8467/8/168/6/16
51Invoice_47Calls26,8907/10/168/10/16
52Invoice_48Texts30,3727/15/168/14/16
53Invoice_49Emails5,9597/19/168/22/16
54Invoice_50Texts43,8707/23/168/27/16
55Invoice_51Texts1,9237/28/169/1/16
56Invoice_52Emails29,9368/1/169/3/16
57Invoice_53Texts22,8218/3/169/6/16
58Invoice_54Calls42,7738/9/169/8/16
59Invoice_55Emails44,9178/11/169/14/16
60Invoice_56Texts42,2358/16/169/16/16
61Invoice_57Calls7,1968/19/169/20/16
62Invoice_58Emails38,8448/21/169/21/16
63Invoice_59Texts44,9118/26/169/28/16
64Invoice_60Calls49,9368/29/169/28/16
65Invoice_61Texts32,1388/31/1610/4/16
66Invoice_62Emails17,1839/6/1610/7/16
67Invoice_63Emails2,4929/11/1610/13/16
68Invoice_64Texts39,0199/16/1610/22/16
69Invoice_65Emails41,3009/20/1610/20/16
70Invoice_66Calls4,6669/22/1610/28/16
71Invoice_67Calls5,6429/26/1610/27/16
72Invoice_68Emails45,1729/30/1610/29/16
73Invoice_69Calls49,37610/2/1611/3/16
74Invoice_70Texts21,13810/6/1611/10/16
75Invoice_71Calls25,14510/11/1611/14/16
76Invoice_72Texts26,19110/13/1611/17/16
77Invoice_73Emails38,27810/19/1611/20/16
78Invoice_74Texts43,72810/24/1611/27/16
79Invoice_75Texts17,04310/28/1611/28/16
80Invoice_76Emails24,82610/30/1611/30/16
81Invoice_77Texts23,81911/3/1612/5/16
82Invoice_78Calls35,19111/5/1612/7/16
83Invoice_79Emails12,76611/10/1612/12/16
84Invoice_80Texts43,28711/12/1612/12/16
85Invoice_81Calls49,10111/17/1612/17/16
86Invoice_82Emails49,36311/20/1612/20/16
87Invoice_83Texts11,78811/26/161/1/17
88Invoice_84Calls22,64911/28/1612/31/16
89Invoice_85Texts31,22312/2/1612/31/16
90Invoice_86Emails34,64912/4/161/4/17
91Invoice_87Emails45,26412/6/161/11/17
92Invoice_88Texts9,96712/8/161/10/17
93Invoice_89Emails13,62512/11/161/15/17
94Invoice_90Calls13,82712/14/161/19/17
Part1_Calendarized_Usage
Cell Formulas
RangeFormula
G6G6=SUM(Part1_Usage_Curves!$E$461:$E$748)/SUM(Part1_Usage_Curves!$E$461:$E$1228)*$D6
H6H6=SUM(Part1_Usage_Curves!E749:E1228)/SUM(Part1_Usage_Curves!$E$461:$E$1228)*$D6
G7G7=SUM(Part1_Usage_Curves!$F$437:$F$748)/SUM(Part1_Usage_Curves!$F$437:$F$1132)*$D7
H7H7=SUM(Part1_Usage_Curves!$F$749:$F$1132)/SUM(Part1_Usage_Curves!$F$437:$F$1132)*$D7
B5:B94B5="Invoice_"&ROW($A5)-ROW($A$4)


The formulas in cells G6 & H6 (provided by the exercise) are what I'm failing to understand.

The formula in G6 is based on the following section in Worksheet 2:

CES Excel Exercise.xlsx
ABCDEF
4611/20/1613.4356.6116.15
4621/20/1623.3855.7015.90
4631/20/1633.3655.8615.82
4641/20/1643.3956.6215.94
4651/20/1653.4858.7016.41
4661/20/1663.6762.4717.35
4671/20/1674.1368.9819.64
4681/20/1684.3873.7520.90
4691/20/1694.4377.1721.16
4701/20/16104.6579.5722.25
4711/20/16114.7079.6722.49
4721/20/16124.6377.9122.13
4731/20/16134.4576.0421.26
4741/20/16144.3775.3920.84
4751/20/16154.2773.3320.33
4761/20/16164.2271.7820.09
4771/20/16174.2070.8320.00
4781/20/16184.2471.2420.22
4791/20/16194.1269.1219.58
4801/20/16204.0769.5719.35
4811/20/16213.8266.9618.08
4821/20/16223.6062.9116.99
4831/20/16233.3958.9215.94
4841/20/16243.2656.0315.30
4851/21/1613.1953.9014.95
4861/21/1623.1353.0814.64
4871/21/1633.1353.1714.64
4881/21/1643.1453.8014.70
4891/21/1653.2456.0115.20
4901/21/1663.4359.6316.15
4911/21/1673.8766.6418.36
4921/21/1684.1772.1619.83
4931/21/1694.2375.4720.15
4941/21/16104.4077.3321.01
4951/21/16114.5077.7821.49
4961/21/16124.4776.3621.36
4971/21/16134.3574.9920.75
4981/21/16144.1172.9119.55
4991/21/16154.1171.9219.56
5001/21/16164.0870.4019.40
5011/21/16174.0369.0219.14
5021/21/16184.0969.6619.47
5031/21/16194.0668.5719.30
5041/21/16203.8066.1017.99
5051/21/16213.6865.0417.42
5061/21/16223.4561.0716.24
5071/21/16233.3057.6815.48
5081/21/16243.2055.4315.00
5091/22/1613.1953.9014.95
5101/22/1623.1353.0814.64
5111/22/1633.1753.7114.87
5121/22/1643.2955.4915.44
5131/22/1653.3457.0815.68
5141/22/1663.5761.3316.87
5151/22/1673.9267.1118.62
5161/22/1684.1171.7719.56
5171/22/1694.1374.6219.64
5181/22/16104.4077.3321.01
5191/22/16114.4577.3021.24
5201/22/16124.4776.3621.36
5211/22/16134.4576.0421.26
5221/22/16144.3775.3920.84
5231/22/16154.4775.2221.35
5241/22/16164.4974.5421.47
5251/22/16174.4273.0921.09
5261/22/16184.5474.4021.71
5271/22/16194.5172.9521.57
5281/22/16204.2371.6620.17
5291/22/16213.9568.8818.75
5301/22/16223.7564.7617.73
5311/22/16233.5360.7916.64
5321/22/16243.4457.8116.18
5331/23/1613.3053.5815.50
5341/23/1623.2552.8715.24
5351/23/1633.2352.4215.17
5361/23/1643.2352.3515.14
5371/23/1653.2353.1615.17
5381/23/1663.2654.4815.31
5391/23/1673.3457.3615.71
5401/23/1683.3958.8615.94
5411/23/1693.4559.8316.26
5421/23/16103.6461.2417.22
5431/23/16113.7662.2017.81
5441/23/16123.8061.9518.01
5451/23/16133.7761.3217.83
5461/23/16143.6960.8717.47
5471/23/16153.6159.8717.05
5481/23/16163.5860.1816.88
5491/23/16173.5860.5316.89
5501/23/16183.7062.6917.50
5511/23/16193.7862.2517.88
5521/23/16203.6562.1117.27
5531/23/16213.5860.0316.90
5541/23/16223.3757.6715.87
5551/23/16233.2255.6315.08
5561/23/16243.1053.8314.51
5571/24/1613.0652.4914.29
5581/24/1622.9750.3913.87
5591/24/1632.9450.4113.72
5601/24/1643.0050.2714.01
5611/24/1653.1852.6514.91
5621/24/1663.3655.3815.82
5631/24/1673.5158.5616.57
5641/24/1683.5559.9616.73
5651/24/1693.5160.2616.55
5661/24/16103.7061.7017.50
5671/24/16113.8262.5518.11
5681/24/16123.8061.9518.01
5691/24/16133.6760.7017.34
5701/24/16143.5159.1616.54
5711/24/16153.3457.9315.71
5721/24/16163.1956.9514.93
5731/24/16173.2257.4215.12
5741/24/16183.4159.7016.06
5751/24/16193.4761.5816.34
5761/24/16203.6562.1117.27
5771/24/16213.6360.5617.14
5781/24/16223.4558.5716.27
5791/24/16233.4455.4116.20
5801/24/16243.3753.5415.86
5811/25/1613.3355.5315.67
5821/25/1623.3355.1815.65
5831/25/1633.4156.4016.06
5841/25/1643.4957.7516.43
5851/25/1653.5359.2316.65
5861/25/1663.7263.0417.59
5871/25/1674.2870.3820.40
5881/25/1684.4974.5521.44
5891/25/1694.5378.0321.67
5901/25/16104.6579.5722.25
5911/25/16114.5578.2521.74
5921/25/16124.4275.8421.10
5931/25/16134.0972.3719.46
5941/25/16143.9070.9318.52
5951/25/16153.8169.0918.03
5961/25/16163.7667.1917.79
5971/25/16173.6865.4117.41
5981/25/16183.9568.0718.73
5991/25/16193.7865.8417.89
6001/25/16203.7465.4017.72
6011/25/16213.4661.8516.32
6021/25/16223.3559.8415.75
6031/25/16233.0253.9514.08
6041/25/16242.8250.0813.10
6051/26/1612.7148.4812.53
6061/26/1622.7148.3812.54
6071/26/1632.7548.8612.74
6081/26/1642.8450.4113.22
6091/26/1652.7750.6412.87
6101/26/1662.9553.9313.75
6111/26/1673.2258.7515.10
6121/26/1683.6164.9117.07
6131/26/1693.5568.2116.73
6141/26/16103.8171.2318.06
6151/26/16113.8170.5218.06
6161/26/16123.8970.1218.44
6171/26/16133.6667.6517.31
6181/26/16143.5466.4716.70
6191/26/16153.3363.5715.67
6201/26/16163.3261.6915.62
6211/26/16173.2261.3515.10
6221/26/16183.2660.6915.31
6231/26/16193.0355.4414.15
6241/26/16203.2860.7215.38
6251/26/16212.8955.8113.46
6261/26/16222.8053.4312.99
6271/26/16232.6049.5212.00
6281/26/16242.3545.0010.75
6291/27/1612.2642.3710.29
6301/27/1622.1140.609.56
6311/27/1632.0940.449.45
6321/27/1642.1242.039.61
6331/27/1652.4344.5811.14
6341/27/1662.6550.2812.24
6351/27/1673.0156.5414.07
6361/27/1683.3462.0815.68
6371/27/1693.4867.4516.39
6381/27/16103.7570.5217.75
6391/27/16113.8771.0718.36
6401/27/16123.8970.1218.44
6411/27/16133.8269.2218.08
6421/27/16143.8268.9518.11
6431/27/16153.7467.6817.70
6441/27/16163.6766.2717.33
6451/27/16173.6464.9617.19
6461/27/16183.7065.4317.49
6471/27/16193.6164.2017.04
6481/27/16203.4261.2316.08
6491/27/16213.3359.9315.66
6501/27/16223.1557.3814.75
6511/27/16233.0253.9514.08
6521/27/16242.7951.2712.94
6531/28/1612.9551.1913.74
6541/28/1622.9350.9913.64
6551/28/1633.0352.0914.16
6561/28/1643.0452.6714.21
6571/28/1653.2456.0115.20
6581/28/1663.3859.0615.91
6591/28/1673.8266.1718.11
6601/28/1684.0671.3719.30
6611/28/1694.1374.6219.64
6621/28/16104.3076.4320.52
6631/28/16114.3075.8920.48
6641/28/16124.2273.7620.08
6651/28/16134.0471.8519.21
6661/28/16143.8570.4418.26
6671/28/16153.8169.0918.03
6681/28/16163.8067.6418.02
6691/28/16173.7766.3117.84
6701/28/16183.7565.9617.74
6711/28/16193.7265.2917.60
6721/28/16203.4761.9316.36
6731/28/16213.3359.9315.66
6741/28/16223.1056.7714.51
6751/28/16232.8852.9813.39
6761/28/16242.8250.0813.10
6771/29/1612.7148.4812.53
6781/29/1622.7148.3812.54
6791/29/1632.8449.9413.22
6801/29/1642.8950.9713.47
6811/29/1653.0053.3213.99
6821/29/1663.2457.3515.19
6831/29/1673.6264.3017.09
6841/29/1683.4162.7916.03
6851/29/1693.6268.9617.08
6861/29/16103.6269.1117.11
6871/29/16113.6969.4217.46
6881/29/16124.0171.6819.05
6891/29/16133.8769.7518.34
6901/29/16143.8570.4418.26
6911/29/16153.8368.6218.15
6921/29/16163.7667.1917.79
6931/29/16173.8166.7718.06
6941/29/16183.8567.0218.23
6951/29/16193.7865.8417.89
6961/29/16203.5863.3216.90
6971/29/16213.4661.8516.32
6981/29/16223.2558.6115.25
6991/29/16233.0654.5714.32
7001/29/16242.9152.4613.53
7011/30/1612.9652.0613.81
7021/30/1622.9750.3913.87
7031/30/1632.9050.0813.48
7041/30/1642.8949.2313.45
7051/30/1652.9250.0713.61
7061/30/1663.0652.6714.28
7071/30/1673.2856.9615.42
7081/30/1683.3958.8615.94
7091/30/1693.3458.9715.69
7101/30/16103.4759.8716.36
7111/30/16113.5260.8116.60
7121/30/16123.4258.5916.11
7131/30/16133.3258.5215.61
7141/30/16143.1856.1514.91
7151/30/16152.9855.3413.92
7161/30/16162.8954.5313.46
7171/30/16172.9254.6913.58
7181/30/16183.1256.7114.62
7191/30/16193.0652.8614.29
7201/30/16202.9655.0113.78
7211/30/16212.9653.1313.82
7221/30/16222.8952.2813.46
7231/30/16232.6346.7012.16
7241/30/16242.5645.1911.78
7251/31/1612.4744.7711.33
7261/31/1622.3743.5310.86
7271/31/1632.3942.8710.95
7281/31/1642.3743.6210.83
7291/31/1652.5445.7911.68
7301/31/1662.5846.4511.88
7311/31/1672.8250.2513.10
7321/31/1682.6650.0512.32
7331/31/1692.8652.0613.29
7341/31/16102.8952.9113.47
7351/31/16112.9653.0513.79
7361/31/16122.9152.7513.57
7371/31/16132.7250.3212.59
7381/31/16142.5748.7411.86
7391/31/16152.3047.2110.52
7401/31/16162.4347.6511.17
7411/31/16172.4648.2411.30
7421/31/16182.5449.7811.72
7431/31/16192.6250.1812.09
7441/31/16202.6149.9212.03
7451/31/16212.5848.6911.90
7461/31/16222.3844.3010.89
7471/31/16232.1742.029.87
7481/31/16242.0139.219.05
Part1_Usage_Curves


CES Excel Exercise.xlsx
ABCDEF
3CallsTextsEmails
4DateHourUsage_Curve_1Usage_Curve_2Usage_Curve_3
Part1_Usage_Curves
 
Upvote 0

Excel Facts

Best way to learn Power Query?
Read M is for (Data) Monkey book by Ken Puls and Miguel Escobar. It is the complete guide to Power Query.
I'll have to work on this more in the morning, if no one else will hop on to find the solution.
 
Upvote 0
Welcome to the MrExcel Message Board!

Cross-posting (posting the same question in more than one forum) is not against our rules, but the method of doing so is covered by #13 of the Forum Rules.

Be sure to follow & read the link at the end of the rule too!

Cross posted at: Losing my mind over this. Is my assignment incorrect or do I just not know what I'm doing?
There is no need to repeat the link(s) provided above but if you have posted the question at other places, please provide links to those as well.

If you do cross-post in the future and also provide links, then there shouldn’t be a problem.
 
Upvote 0

Forum statistics

Threads
1,224,818
Messages
6,181,151
Members
453,021
Latest member
Justyna P

We've detected that you are using an adblocker.

We have a great community of people providing Excel help here, but the hosting costs are enormous. You can help keep this site running by allowing ads on MrExcel.com.
Allow Ads at MrExcel

Which adblocker are you using?

Disable AdBlock

Follow these easy steps to disable AdBlock

1)Click on the icon in the browser’s toolbar.
2)Click on the icon in the browser’s toolbar.
2)Click on the "Pause on this site" option.
Go back

Disable AdBlock Plus

Follow these easy steps to disable AdBlock Plus

1)Click on the icon in the browser’s toolbar.
2)Click on the toggle to disable it for "mrexcel.com".
Go back

Disable uBlock Origin

Follow these easy steps to disable uBlock Origin

1)Click on the icon in the browser’s toolbar.
2)Click on the "Power" button.
3)Click on the "Refresh" button.
Go back

Disable uBlock

Follow these easy steps to disable uBlock

1)Click on the icon in the browser’s toolbar.
2)Click on the "Power" button.
3)Click on the "Refresh" button.
Go back
Back
Top